Asking range
$259,426 – $1.33M
Median ask $399,448
For sale now
45
US + Canada listings
Top auction sale
$1.49M
RM Sotheby's · Aug 2026
7-day change
-1.4%
Median ask vs a week ago
About the 458 Italia
The 458 Italia is the car that showed what a modern mid-engined V8 Ferrari could feel like. Unveiled at the 2009 Frankfurt Motor Show as the successor to the F430, it was an entirely new design shaped by Ferrari's Formula One experience, with input from Michael Schumacher on a cockpit that puts the main controls on the steering wheel. At its heart sits a 4.5-litre naturally aspirated V8 that revs all the way to 9,000 rpm, where it makes 570 PS. It was also the first mid-engined Ferrari road car with direct fuel injection. Clever touches abound, like front grille winglets that flex at speed to cut drag. The press loved it: Top Gear named it Car of the Year 2009 and Motor Trend called it the Best Driver's Car in 2011. Today it is cherished as one of the last naturally aspirated mid-engined V8 Ferraris before the turbocharged 488 GTB took over in 2015.
Engine4.5-litre naturally aspirated V8
Power570 PS at 9,000 rpm
Debut2009 Frankfurt Motor Show
ReplacedF430
Replaced by488 GTB (2015)
Sources: Wikipedia: Ferrari 458
Median asking price trend
Median ask
30-day change
-11.2% ▼
90-day change
—
High (30 days)
$455,675
Low (30 days)
$394,995
Ferrari 458 Italia Market Analysis
Asking prices for the 458 Italia are softening: the median is down 11.2% in a month.
- Price trendMedian ask down 11.2% since Sep 18, 2026. ▼
- InventoryUp from 27 to 45 cars listed; more supply usually means more room to negotiate. This week: 8 new, 6 off the market.
- Price cuts17 sellers cut the ask on the same car in the past week (median 2.4%), vs 0 increases. ▼
- Vs. auctionsRecent sales cleared at a median of $501,000, 25% above the median ask, pointing to solid demand for the best-presented cars.
- Watch forA few asks sit far above the pack (top ask $1,329,888), usually special-spec or very low-mileage cars; the median is the better guide.
Upcoming and live auctions View all auctions →
US and Canada
| Lot | Sale · location | Date | Estimate / bid | Auction house |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia | Rosso Eterno Collection, Rosso Corsa | Online · Lebanon, Tennessee | Oct 20, 2026 | $85,500 current bid | duPont REGISTRY Live |
| 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia | Nero Daytona, $50k in Options | Online · Lebanon, Tennessee | Oct 20, 2026 | $129,000 current bid | duPont REGISTRY Live |
Estimates and bids are shown as each auction house publishes them, in its own currency. A live bid is not a final price.
Recent auction results View all auctions →
| Date | Year | Miles | Venue | Result | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Oct 20, 2026 | 2012 | 27,274 | duPont REGISTRY | Current bid | $85,500 | ↗ |
| Oct 20, 2026 | 2011 | 21,183 | duPont REGISTRY | Current bid | $129,000 | ↗ |
| Oct 9, 2026 | 2014 | 12,000 | Bring a Trailer | Sold | $355,000 | ↗ |
| Sep 24, 2026 | 2012 | 9,000 | Bring a Trailer | Sold | $341,000 | ↗ |
| Sep 21, 2026 | 2011 | 40,000 | Bring a Trailer | Sold | $234,117 | ↗ |
| Aug 21, 2026 | 2012 | — | Bring a Trailer | Not sold (high bid) | $350,000 | ↗ |
| Aug 19, 2026 | 2015 | 1,800 | Bring a Trailer | Sold | $501,000 | ↗ |
| Aug 15, 2026 | 2015 | — | RM Sotheby's | Sold | $1,490,000 | ↗ |
| Aug 15, 2026 | 2015 | — | Mecum | Sold | $1,210,000 | ↗ |
| Aug 14, 2026 | 2015 | — | Gooding & Company | Sold | $1,022,500 | ↗ |
Buying a Ferrari 458 Italia?
Half of the 458 Italias listed are asking less than $399,448.
- Price rangeCurrent asks run from $259,426 to $1,329,888.
- Negotiation17 price cuts in the past week show room to negotiate, especially on the higher asks.
- Reference pointRecent auction median $501,000, 25% above the median ask.
- CheckCompare mileage, options and service history across several cars before anchoring on one ask.
Notable sales
The cars that set the market
No image available
RM Sotheby's · Aug 2026
$1,490,000
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
View lot →
No image available
Mecum · Aug 2026
$1,210,000
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
View lot →
No image available
Gooding & Company · Aug 2026
$1,022,500
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
View lot →
Photo: Bring a TrailerBring a Trailer · Aug 2026
$501,000
1,800-Mile 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia · 1800 miles
View lot →
Photo: Bring a TrailerBring a Trailer · Aug 2026
$470,000
1,200-Mile 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia · 1200 miles
View lot →
Listed for sale
Listed For Sale
Latest listings 45
Days tracked = how long we’ve seen this listing in our daily tracking.
| Model | Body | Year | Ask (USD) | First ask | Since tracked | Days tracked | Miles | Ext | Int | Location | Seller | Source | Title | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $1,329,888 | $1,338,888 | −$9k / −0.7% | 41 | — | — | — | San Luis Obispo, California, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2015 | $590,084 | $599,999 | −$10k / −1.7% | 23 | — | — | — | Costa Mesa, California, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2015 | $499,999 | $530,084 | −$30k / −5.7% | 31 | — | — | — | Costa Mesa, California, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2013 | $490,489 | $489,890 | +$599 / +0.1% | 9 | 2,275 | Rosso Corsa | Beige | St Louis, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2014 | $475,988 | $479,988 | −$4k / −0.8% | 41 | — | — | — | Pompano Beach, Florida, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2014 | $459,995 | $529,995 | −$70k / −13.2% | 41 | — | — | — | Tampa, Florida, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia 2DR Cpe |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $454,890 | $459,900 | −$5k / −1.1% | 38 | 4,934 | Nero | Nero | Norwood, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2013 | $450,694 | — | — | 9 | 10,542 | Rosso Corsa | Beige | Naples, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $450,489 | $469,890 | −$19k / −4.1% | 32 | 3,393 | Nero | Crema | St Louis, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2015 | $449,995 | $539,995 | −$90k / −16.7% | 41 | 4,383 | Red | Brown | City of Glen Cove, New York, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2014 | $439,995 | $449,995 | −$10k / −2.2% | 27 | 8,335 | Red | Black | City of Glen Cove, New York, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2013 | $429,995 | $449,995 | −$20k / −4.4% | 30 | 7,280 | White | Red | San Clemente, California, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2015 | $429,000 | $479,000 | −$50k / −10.4% | 41 | 9,438 | Rosso Corsa | Nero | Boca Raton, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2015 | $419,122 | — | — | 12 | 25,163 | red | — | ZIP 94941, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $414,890 | $417,900 | −$3k / −0.7% | 38 | 11,536 | Rosso Corsa | Beige | Norwood, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2015 | $409,995 | — | — | 26 | 13,317 | Grigio Silverstone Metallic | Rosso | Beverly Hills, California, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2011 | $401,685 | — | — | 2 | 7,138 | Bianco Avus | Nero | Naples, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2012 | $400,894 | $416,626 | −$16k / −3.8% | 38 | 16,601 | red | — | ZIP 28217, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2011 | $399,999 | $459,999 | −$60k / −13.0% | 41 | 7,875 | Nero Daytona | Nero | DuPage County, Illinois, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2011 | $399,995 | $439,995 | −$40k / −9.1% | 36 | 11,270 | Yellow | Black | — | dealer | dupontregistry | 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2013 | $399,900 | — | — | 41 | 13,236 | Red | Beige | Las Vegas, Nevada, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2014 | $399,650 | $468,573 | −$69k / −14.7% | 41 | 8,842 | Red | Brown (Tan) | Carrollton, Texas, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2012 | $399,448 | $415,448 | −$16k / −3.9% | 39 | — | — | — | Canton, Ohio, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $395,000 | $429,900 | −$35k / −8.1% | 41 | 8,313 | Rosso Corsa | Beige | Lake Bluff, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2014 | $394,990 | — | — | 41 | 15,644 | black | — | ZIP 80216, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2011 | $391,443 | — | — | 4 | 13,386 | Blu Tour De France | Beige | Wilsonville, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2014 | $390,125 | — | — | 11 | 11,427 | Grigio Silverstone | Cuoio | Plano, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $389,995 | $399,995 | −$10k / −2.5% | 38 | — | — | — | ZIP 90212, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2012 | $386,926 | $389,970 | −$3k / −0.8% | 4 | 11,144 | Bianco Avus | Nero | Spring Valley Rockland County New York, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2012 | $380,072 | $380,035 | +$37 / 0.0% | 38 | 18,792 | red | — | ZIP 91406, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2013 | $369,900 | $367,489 | +$2k / +0.7% | 12 | 17,772 | yellow | — | ZIP 75093, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2014 | $360,687 | $359,989 | +$698 / +0.2% | 30 | 5,605 | Nero | Nero | Phoenix, USA | dealer | Ferrari Approved (preowned.ferrari.com) | 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $359,990 | $369,900 | −$10k / −2.7% | 12 | 25,385 | black | — | ZIP 27409, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $349,712 | $379,708 | −$30k / −7.9% | 38 | 20,822 | red | — | ZIP 78006, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2014 | $349,063 | $350,295 | −$1k / −0.4% | 1 | 21,239 | black | — | ZIP 10977, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2012 | $346,696 | — | — | 11 | 19,725 | — | — | ZIP 33181, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2011 | $344,995 | — | — | 2 | — | — | — | Solon, Ohio, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2011 | $339,995 | — | — | 41 | — | — | — | Zionsville, Indiana, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2011 | $331,190 | $326,389 | +$5k / +1.5% | 12 | 35,439 | yellow | — | ZIP 20147, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2015 | $329,995 | — | — | 6 | — | — | — | Houston, Texas, USA | dealer | Classic.com | 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $319,162 | $380,072 | −$61k / −16.0% | 12 | 37,761 | red | — | ZIP 94061, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2011 | $304,900 | $319,900 | −$15k / −4.7% | 38 | 25,845 | gray | — | ZIP 28227, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2014 | $300,497 | $330,497 | −$30k / −9.1% | 37 | 7,205 | Nero Noctis Black | Black | Las Vegas, NV | dealer | CarGurus | 2014 Ferrari 458 |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2011 | $289,900 | $461,584 | −$172k / −37.2% | 12 | 39,693 | red | — | ZIP 75244, USA | dealer | Cars.com | 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Base |
| 🔍 | 458 | coupe | 2010 | $259,426 | $296,081 | −$37k / −12.4% | 35 | 13,821 | — | — | Tampa, FL | dealer | CarGurus | 2010 Ferrari 458 |
Compare Similar Models
488 Spider$399,000▼ 0.2%
›
296 GTS$430,404▼ 0.1%
›
296 GTB$349,999▲ 0.2%
›
F8 Tributo$460,965▼ 1.0%
›Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a Ferrari 458 Italia cost in 2026?
As of Oct 18, 2026, the median asking price for a Ferrari 458 Italia in the US and Canada is $399,448, across 45 cars for sale. Asking prices are where negotiations start, not final sale prices.
Is the 458 Italia appreciating or depreciating?
The median ask is down 11.2% over the past 30 days and down 1.4% over the past week. Short-term moves partly reflect which cars are listed.
How many 458 Italia cars are for sale?
We count 45 active listings in the US and Canada, up from 42 a week earlier.
What engine does the 458 Italia have?
The 458 Italia uses a 4.5-liter naturally aspirated V8, rated at 562 hp.
What have 458 Italias sold for at auction?
We recorded 7 auction sales in the past 90 days, with a median of $501,000.
Price guides
Explore price guides
Hypercars
- Apollo Intensa Emozione
- Aston Martin One-77
- Aston Martin Valhalla
- Aston Martin Valkyrie
- Aston Martin Valour
- Bugatti Bolide
- Bugatti Centodieci
- Bugatti Chiron
- Bugatti Divo
- Bugatti Tourbillon
- Bugatti Veyron
- Bugatti W16 Mistral
- Czinger 21C
- De Tomaso P72
- Gordon Murray T.33
- Gordon Murray T.50
- Hennessey Blackbird
- Hennessey Venom F5
- Hennessey Venom GT
- Kimera EVO37
- Koenigsegg Agera
- Koenigsegg CC850
- Koenigsegg CCX & CCXR
- Koenigsegg Gemera
- Koenigsegg Jesko
- Koenigsegg One:1
- Koenigsegg Regera
- Lotus Evija
- Mercedes-AMG One
- Pagani Huayra
- Pagani Utopia
- Pagani Zonda
- Pininfarina Battista
- Rimac Nevera
- SSC Tuatara